Post-foam attic humidity usually traces to one of three things: (a) inadequate mechanical ventilation in a tightened envelope, (b) trapped moisture from pre-existing leaks the foam encapsulated, or (c) wrong product choice (open-cell at a vapor-critical surface). All three are fixable; the diagnosis requires a thermal imaging walkthrough and a moisture meter.
More detail
Post-foam attic moisture is the single most common Cincinnati homeowner concern in the months after install. The three diagnostic categories. (1) Inadequate ventilation in a tightened envelope. A home that tested 8-10 ACH50 pre-foam may now test 4-5 ACH50, dropping below the 0.35 ACH continuous that ASHRAE 62.2 recommends. Indoor moisture from cooking, showering, breathing, and houseplants accumulates because natural infiltration no longer dilutes it. The attic, often the coldest surface in the home, sees condensation. Fix: install an HRV or ERV sized to the home, typically $2,500-$5,000 retrofit. (2) Pre-existing leak the foam encapsulated. Active roof leaks, plumbing leaks in walls, or condensation from cold-water pipes may have been visible (or audible) before the foam install and were not remediated first. The foam now traps the moisture against organic substrates. Fix: identify the leak source (thermal imaging from inside the conditioned space typically reveals it), remediate the leak, remove and replace the affected foam. (3) Wrong product at a vapor-critical surface. Open-cell foam sprayed on the underside of the roof deck in a conditioned-attic design lets vapor migrate through to the roof sheathing, where it condenses against the cold deck. Fix: remove the open-cell, replace with closed-cell, or add a vapor retarder layer. The diagnostic process for a Cincinnati homeowner facing this issue. Start with a moisture meter reading on the attic framing and roof deck (acceptable: under 19% moisture content). Then a thermal imaging walkthrough during a cold January morning to find cold spots that indicate air-leak paths or condensation surfaces. Then a humidity meter reading in the attic vs the living space; an attic that runs 10+ percentage points above conditioned space humidity points to either trapped moisture or ventilation deficit. Most Cincinnati post-foam moisture complaints resolve within 60 days of identifying the root cause; persistent issues beyond that timeline indicate a structural diagnosis the homeowner should have a credentialed installer revisit.