The rim joist (where foundation meets framing). 4-6 hours of work, $800-$1,500, often delivers 10-15% utility savings. Highest ROI of any home-energy project. Then attic. Then walls.
More detail
Rim joist is the universal Cincinnati first project for two reasons. (1) Per-dollar utility savings: 4-6 hours of closed-cell foam on the rim joist band typically reduces total household utility bills 10-15%, paying back in 18-24 months. (2) It addresses both air leakage (rim joist is the worst air-seal failure point in 90% of pre-2000 Cincinnati homes) and thermal weakness (uninsulated rim joist runs at near-outdoor temperature in winter, chilling adjacent floors). The priority ladder for full retrofit: 1st rim joist, 2nd attic (largest surface area, highest stack-effect impact), 3rd walls (drill-and-fill if existing siding stays; full open-cavity if siding comes off), 4th crawl space (encapsulate and foam), 5th basement walls (closed-cell continuous on the interior). Following this ladder, most Cincinnati homes hit 25-45% utility savings by step 2 and 50%+ savings by step 5. Cincinnati incremental-budget-planning: many homeowners can't afford whole-home foam upfront but can budget $2,000-$3,500/year for incremental envelope upgrades. Year 1: rim joist + utility-cost-driven priority (often attic). Year 2: walls or crawl space depending on baseline. Year 3: any remaining envelope plus ventilation upgrade. Our Cincinnati installers can scope multi-year project plans during the initial assessment.